Lesson 1.11, two days. Day 1: eleven slides. Day 2: twelve slides. Build the deck from this outline. Student-facing text reads at grade 6 to 7.
Day 1: Reading the evidence
Do now
- Look at the package on your table. Do not turn it over.
- Is this a healthy food? Yes or no, and one reason.
- Two minutes.
Teacher notes
Hands up for yes, hands up for no. Then: "Everything you used to decide came from the front. The front is an ad. Turn it over."
The front is an ad. The back is the evidence.
- A label detective reads the back first.
- The back has a box the government makes every company fill in the same way.
- It is called Nutrition Facts.
- Same order, same words, every package. Once you can read one, you can read all of them.
Teacher notes
Image: a cereal box front with bright colors and claims next to its plain black and white Nutrition Facts panel.
The label, top to bottom
- Servings per container: how many servings are in the whole package.
- Serving size: the amount all the numbers describe. The government sets it, not the company.
- Calories: big and bold on purpose.
- Then the nutrients, then percent daily value down the right side.
Teacher notes
Image: a full Nutrition Facts label, large, with letters A through G next to the parts the handout asks for.
Students label the diagram on the handout as you go. Serving size first, always.
Get less, get more
- Get LESS of these: saturated fat, sodium, added sugars.
- Get MORE of these: dietary fiber, vitamin D, calcium, iron, potassium.
- Added sugars is new (2020). It separates the sugar in fruit or milk from the sugar the company put in.
- Total sugars minus added sugars is the sugar that was already there.
Teacher notes
Image: the label with the "get less" lines circled in one color and the "get more" lines in another.
Percent daily value
- % DV means: how much of a whole day's worth one serving gives you.
- Based on a 2,000 calorie day.
- It is NOT the percent of the food. It is the percent of your day.
- Sodium 9% DV means one serving uses up 9% of your sodium for the whole day.
Teacher notes
This is the misconception to kill today. Say "percent of your day" every time.
The 5 and 20 rule
- 5% DV or less is LOW.
- 20% DV or more is HIGH.
- Low is good for the get less list. High is good for the get more list.
- Try it: sodium ______% DV on our label. Low, in between, or high? Fiber ______%?
Teacher notes
Image: a number line from 0 to 100 with 5 and 20 marked.
Fill in from the poster label. Two examples out loud, then the students do them on the handout.
The servings trap
- The label describes ONE serving.
- This bag has ______ servings. [Sal: your poster label.]
- Eat the bag, multiply everything by ______.
- Calories: ______ x ______ = ______. Sodium: ______ x ______ = ______ mg.
Teacher notes
Do sodium out loud. Students do calories on the handout.
The Label Scavenger Hunt
- Five packages at your station. Serving size first, then everything else.
- Part 1: fill one row per package on the table.
- Part 2: answer the six hunt questions. Every answer has a package name AND a number.
- "It looks unhealthy" is not evidence. A number is.
- Fifteen minutes.
Teacher notes
Clipboard checklist: reads serving size before calories; gives a number as evidence; found the 20% or more item correctly.
Rotate (optional)
- At seven minutes, teams move one station to the right.
- Take your handout. Leave the packages.
- Finish the table with the new packages.
Teacher notes
Use this slide only if you want every team to see all fifteen packages. Skip it if the room is tight.
Share
- One question per team. Read the answer and the evidence.
- Class: was the evidence a number?
- The class "most sodium per serving" and "most added sugars" go on the board and stay up until tomorrow.
Teacher notes
Leave the two numbers on the board for the Day 2 do now.
Exit card
- 3 parts of a Nutrition Facts label and what each one tells you.
- 2 numbers from a package you read today, with the package name.
- 1 question you still have about labels.
- Three volunteers read one line.
- * *
Day 2: Spot the trick
Teacher notes
Sort into "got it" and "needs more."
Do now
- A cereal box says "Made with whole grain."
- Does that mean it is healthy? Yes, no, or it depends.
- What would you need to see to be sure?
- One minute.
Teacher notes
Most say "it depends." "Good. Today you find out what it depends on, and then you catch a company in the act."
Trick 1, the serving size game
- A 20 ounce bottle. The label says 2.5 servings.
- Who drinks 40% of a bottle and puts it back?
- The numbers look small because the serving is small.
- Catch it with: servings per container. Then multiply.
Teacher notes
Image: a 20 ounce soda bottle with "2.5 servings" circled on its label.
Trick 2, "natural"
- The FDA has never formally defined "natural" for most foods.
- So it can go on almost anything. It does not mean healthy, organic, or low in sugar.
- Catch it with: the ingredient list. What is actually in it?
Teacher notes
Image: three very different packages (chips, a juice drink, candy) all with the word "natural" on the front.
FDA's page "Use of the Term Natural on Food Labeling" says the agency has a longstanding policy but no formal definition. [Sal: check for a 2025 or 2026 update.]
Trick 3, true but beside the point
- "Fat free" on candy. Candy never had fat. Look at added sugars.
- "Made with real fruit." How much? Where is fruit on the ingredient list?
- "Multigrain" means more than one grain. It does not mean whole grain. Look for "whole" as the first word of the first ingredient.
- Catch it with: the line the claim is not talking about.
Teacher notes
Image: a gummy snack package with "made with real fruit" on the front and an ingredient list starting with corn syrup.
Trick 4, the health halo
- A green package. A leaf. The word "wellness" or "fit" or "smart."
- None of those is a fact.
- Your brain reads the color before it reads the label. Companies know that.
- Catch it with: ignore the front. Read the back.
Teacher notes
Image: two identical labels, one on a bright green package with a leaf and one on a plain package.
Trick 5, three kinds of "less sugar"
- "No sugar added": nothing was put in, but the food may still be full of natural sugar. 100% juice is the classic case.
- "Sugar free": less than half a gram per serving.
- "Reduced sugar": at least 25% less than the regular version. Which can still be a lot.
- Catch it with: total sugars AND added sugars.
Teacher notes
Definitions from FDA labeling rules. The fix for all five tricks is the same: turn it over and find the line.
Comparison 1, the juice aisle
- Product A: 100% orange juice. Product B: an orange drink.
- Both say "excellent source of vitamin C."
- Fill the compare table. Circle the better choice. Name the trick on the front.
- Whole container: if you drank all of B, how many grams of added sugars?
Teacher notes
Image: two cartons side by side, labels on the handout.
B is 10% juice; the vitamin C is added as ascorbic acid. 8 servings x 28 g = 224 g added sugars in the bottle, about 4.5 days' worth.
Comparison 2, the chip aisle
- Product C: veggie straws. "Made with real vegetables. 30% less fat."
- Product D: potato chips. "Made with real potatoes."
- Which wins on calories? Fat? Sodium? Fiber? Protein? Vitamins?
- Is either one a health food?
Teacher notes
C wins calories and fat; D wins sodium, fiber, protein, and vitamins. The vegetable in C is powder, sixth on the list, with no vitamin A or C to show for it. "Neither is a health food" is the best answer.
The ad
- SunBurst Fruit Bites. "Made with REAL fruit. Fat free. Excellent source of vitamin C. The healthy snack for active kids."
- Here is the back of the box. [Show the label and the ingredient list from the handout.]
- Write a four-sentence critique: the claim, then three pieces of evidence from the label or ingredients that the claim hides.
- Frame: "The ad says ___, but the label shows ___."
Teacher notes
Image: the ad as described on the handout: a smiling kid on a soccer field holding a pouch, strawberries and oranges across the package.
Model one sentence: "The ad says 'made with real fruit,' but the first ingredient is corn syrup." Ten minutes.
One apple, for comparison
- A medium apple: 95 calories, 4 g fiber, 0 g added sugars, 0 mg sodium.
- One pouch of Fruit Bites: 90 calories, 0 g fiber, 11 g added sugars.
- Same calories. Not the same food.
- Grade 8 stretch: design an honest label for a snack that could truthfully say "made with real fruit."
Teacher notes
Image: a whole apple next to a small gummy pouch.
Share
- Three critiques read aloud.
- Class: which piece of evidence was the strongest?
- Would the company let this critique run as a commercial? Why not?
Teacher notes
Keep the best three critiques; they become the review slide before the quiz.
Exit ticket
- One product from today.
- The trick on its front.
- The one label line that catches it.
- One sentence. Three volunteers read.
Teacher notes
The "needs more" pile decides which trick gets a review slide at the start of Lesson 1.12. Optional homework: bring an empty package from home whose front makes a claim.